Skin Laboratory Pubilc Company Limited.SET: SKIN🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2025

Internal Control — Board Opinion

Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control

The Board of Directors has considered and assessed the adequacy of the internal control system in accordance with the guidelines of the SEC, covering all 5 aspects: organizational internal control, risk assessment, management's operational control, information and communication systems, and monitoring systems. The Board is of the opinion that the company has an adequate and appropriate internal control system for its business operations. Personnel are adequately allocated to ensure efficient operations, and there is a comprehensive system to monitor all of the company's operations.

In addition, the Audit Committee has reviewed the internal control system and operational systems through coordination with external auditors, internal auditors, and management to ensure that financial reporting is reliable and adequately disclosed. Furthermore, it also ensures that operations comply with the Securities and Exchange Act, as well as regulations related to business operations. The Audit Committee's report is prepared and submitted to the Board of Directors, while also emphasizing good corporate governance.

Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkDetail
The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO)

The Board of Directors has considered and assessed the adequacy of the internal control system in accordance with the guidelines of the SEC, covering all 5 aspects: Organizational Internal Control, Risk Assessment, Management's Operational Control, Information Systems and Communication, and Monitoring Systems. The Board is of the opinion that the company possesses an adequate and appropriate internal control system for its business operations. Personnel are sufficiently allocated to ensure efficient operations, and there is a comprehensive system for monitoring all of the company's operations. This helps to summarize and emphasize the adequacy and appropriateness of the internal controls.

Internal Control Deficiencies

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)4345

Deficiency Details

Period TypeStart Period (YYYY-MM)End Period (YYYY-MM)DetailProgress StatusCorrective Action
month/year Range2025-072025-09
Procurement Cycle: Retrospective Purchase Order Creation It was detected that a purchase order (PO) was created retrospectively for 1 item after the goods had been ordered online and received. This poses a risk of purchases exceeding the budget or not receiving approval from authorized personnel prior to the actual purchase.
Incident no longer subject to action

Emphasize strict adherence to the procurement manual by verifying approval before creating a Purchase Order (PO). (Follow-up audit in Q4/2025 found no additional issues.)

month/year Range2025-072025-09
Procurement Cycle: Closing Outstanding Purchase Orders in the System. One instance of closing an outstanding purchase order in the system was found without evidence of notification from the relevant department. This was due to a misunderstanding by the officer, resulting in report data that does not reflect the actual situation and an inability to confirm whether all goods were received.
Incident no longer subject to action

Procurement officers are mandated to verify the status of purchase orders in conjunction with the requesting department prior to closing the item. Should a cancellation be required, notification must be submitted via email exclusively to the Procurement Manager, and the matter must be duly resolved. (To be completed by November 1, 2025)

month/year Range2025-072025-09
Information Technology General Controls (IT General Controls) Finding: The company collects log files but lacks a review process to detect anomalies, such as system access outside business hours or extensive document modifications by a Super User. This results in an absence of a monitoring process, potentially leading to abnormal activities going unnoticed.
Implemented

Log file reviews are mandated, and risk reports are to be summarized and submitted to management via email quarterly. This also includes reviewing the IT operational manual to encompass log reviews. This process is currently underway, with reviews having commenced in Q4/2025. Nevertheless, further evidence to ascertain the cause of notable activities still requires follow-up in Q1/2026.

month/year Range2025-102025-12
Revenue Cycle: Accuracy of Consignment Sales Summary Report. It was found that one monthly sales summary report from a consignment partner was incorrect (overstated amount). This was due to the use of promotional pricing data that was not in accordance with what had been approved. This resulted in a lack of reliability in financial reports and could lead to disputes with the partner.
Incident no longer subject to action

The Business Development Department shall record sales prices according to the approved Price List and promotions, and must send an email notification to the Accounting/Finance Department every time promotions are updated for verification prior to billing. In progress (corrective measures to commence from January 2026 onwards).

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

Yes

Auditor's Observations

Control of products containing controlled substances as per the Ministry of Public Health's announcement

The inspection did not find a separation of product codes (SKU) between products containing controlled substances as per the Ministry of Public Health's announcement (prohibited for use in product manufacturing) and products with newly revised formulations compliant with the law. This may result in an inability to accurately identify and control the inventory balance of prohibited substances.

Recommendations
The company should clearly separate product codes (SKU) between products containing controlled substances as per the Ministry of Public Health's announcement and products with newly revised formulations compliant with the law, to ensure accurate identification of quantities and control of inventory balances for products containing prohibited substances.

Management's Opinion

The company can clearly identify the quantity of products that have been discontinued due to controlled substance issues in the warehouse. This is because the company has designated separate storage areas and prohibited their sale in the system (controlled by batch and storage location) to prevent these products from being mixed with other items.

The company did not separate product codes in this case, as there are other measures that can clearly control and identify the quantity of products in that lot. Changing product codes in this instance would unnecessarily incur costs for both the company and its partners.

However, the company will consider separating new product codes every time there is a risk in controlling product movement and inventory balances.

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3160

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

The Audit Committee has considered the qualifications and performance, as well as the expertise of JP Tip Audit Co., Ltd. ("JPTIP"), with Mr. Tanongsak Padistarn as the primary person responsible for performing the duties of the internal auditor. Having considered the qualifications of JPTIP and Mr. Tanongsak Padistarn, such as experience, educational background, training history, and work history, it is deemed that they are sufficiently suitable for performing such duties, as they are independent, possess knowledge and understanding in auditing various departments, and have experience in internal audit work. The internal auditor reports the results of the internal audit directly to the Audit Committee. Furthermore, the internal auditor adheres to the professional practice standards for internal auditing, which are established by the Institute of Internal Auditors of Thailand.

The Audit Committee has monitored the company's operations within the scope, authority, duties, and responsibilities assigned, by utilizing its knowledge and abilities with due care and prudence, and has maintained independence in performing its duties, having received excellent information and cooperation from the company's management. The Audit Committee is of the opinion that the company has prepared its financial statements accurately in all material respects in accordance with accounting standards and financial reporting standards. The company has adequately disclosed related party transactions or transactions that may give rise to conflicts of interest. It has internal control systems and internal control system reviews, as well as risk management appropriate to the nature of the business. It has complied with relevant laws correctly and completely, and has adhered to good corporate governance principles.

Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Description

The Audit Committee is responsible for considering the independence of the internal audit unit, as well as approving the appointment, transfer, or dismissal of the head of the internal audit unit or any other unit responsible for internal auditing. It may also recommend a review or audit of any items deemed necessary and important, and present recommendations for significant and necessary improvements to the internal control system to the Board of Directors, in conjunction with external auditors. The Audit Committee has monitored the company's operations within the scope, authority, duties, and responsibilities assigned, exercising knowledge and ability with due care and prudence. It has maintained independence in performing its duties, receiving excellent information and cooperation from the company's management. The Audit Committee is of the opinion that the company has prepared its financial statements accurately in all material respects in accordance with accounting standards and financial reporting standards. The company has adequately disclosed related party transactions or transactions that may give rise to conflicts of interest. It has an internal control system and internal control review, as well as risk management appropriate to the nature of the business. It has complied correctly and completely with relevant laws, and has adhered to the principles of good corporate governance.

Related Party Transactions

Has Related Party Transactions

Yes

Counterparties & Transactions

Monetary Unit

1

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
Belink Media Company LimitedJuristic PersonEngages in television program production

Directors and joint shareholders

2025-12-31T00:00
Mr. Chanvit KhieonavavongsaPerson

Mr. Chanvit Khieonavavongsa, Authorized Director / Vice Chairman / Chief Executive Officer / Head of Accounting and Finance (Acting) / Major Shareholder with a 25.35% stake

2025-12-31T00:00

Transactions by Counterparty

Transactions
28246.02 · Necessity: The directors have made advance payments on behalf of the company for certain items. This was necessary to support the company's continuous operations and financial liquidity, as these items primarily involved expenses requiring urgent action. · Description: Details of trade payables and other current payables are advance payments made by directors, comprising accommodation deposits for seminar projects, client entertainment expenses, and employee welfare for gold as an honorary award for employees with 5 years of service. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Trade and other current payables · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are essential for the company's business operations, as they involve advance payments for expenses related to the company's normal operations to ensure continuous and flexible operations. The terms and conditions of these transactions are appropriate, reasonable, and do not cause damage to the company and its shareholders as a whole. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
114689.02 · Necessity: The Company engages in ordinary course of business transactions with Blink Media Co., Ltd. for the production of advertising and public relations media. The pricing and commercial terms are consistent with market rates, similar to transactions with unrelated third parties. · Description: Trade payables and other current payables are expenses related to the production of advertising and public relations media, including the organization of sales promotion activities. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Trade and other current payables · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transaction constitutes a normal business transaction, conducted under general commercial terms. Therefore, such transactions are necessary for the Company's operations, and the commercial terms are reasonable and for the Company's best interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
1448519.99 · Necessity: The Company conducts normal business transactions with Blink Media Co., Ltd. for the production of advertising and public relations media, with pricing and commercial terms determined at market rates, similar to transactions with third parties. · Description: Details of advertising media production costs include: - Media production costs for Roadshow activities - Production costs for advertising media on public transportation - Production costs for billboard advertising · As of yesteryear: 733502.0 · Nature of transaction: Advertising Media Production Fees · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are ordinary business transactions, conducted under general commercial terms. Therefore, these transactions are essential for the Company's business operations, and the commercial terms are reasonable and serve the best interests of the Company. · As of year before yesteryear: 732610.0
1128979.85 · Necessity: Due to credit limit restrictions on the corporate credit card during the aforementioned period, the director advanced payment for advertising expenses through the Shopee and Facebook platforms to support the company's marketing activities. The company is obligated to reimburse the actual expenses incurred. · Description: This is a reimbursement for advertising expenses paid using a director's personal credit card for the company's marketing activities on Shopee and Facebook platforms. · As of yesteryear: 165286.0 · Nature of transaction: Credit Card Creditor - Held by Related Parties · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee has considered and is of the opinion that the aforementioned transaction is necessary for the company's normal business operations, as it involves the provision for operating expenses to ensure continuous operations. Furthermore, the terms and conditions of the transaction are appropriate, reasonable, and do not cause damage to the company and its shareholders as a whole. · As of year before yesteryear: 2637038.39

Policy & Future Trends

Future Trends in Related Party Transactions

For connected transactions, the Company shall comply with the criteria of the Securities and Exchange Act B.E. 2535 (including any amendments), regulations, announcements, orders, and relevant criteria of the Stock Exchange of Thailand and/or the Securities and Exchange Commission and/or the Capital Market Supervisory Board, as well as the requirements for disclosing related party transactions in the notes to the financial statements audited or reviewed by the Company's auditor and/or the annual registration statement/annual report (Form 56-1 One-Report). The measures and procedures for approving related party transactions and connected transactions are as follows:

  • In cases where the Company needs to enter into any contract or engage in related party transactions with subsidiaries, associated companies, related companies, and/or third parties, the Company will consider the necessity and appropriateness of such contracts, primarily considering the Company's benefits. The transactions will be conducted under market or fair price conditions, using the same prices and terms as transactions with third parties, or prices close to market rates. This may include price comparisons with third parties or using reports from independent appraisers to ensure that such prices are reasonable and for the Company's maximum benefit.

  • The Company will conduct transactions deemed as connected transactions according to the Stock Exchange's criteria, accurately and completely, and ensure they are reviewed and commented upon by the Audit Committee, in cases requiring consideration by the Board of Directors and/or the shareholders' meeting.

  • In the future, if there are subsidiaries or associated companies, financial assistance transactions with subsidiaries or associated companies, such as working capital in the form of borrowing, lending, or debt guarantees, will be considered with caution for the maximum benefit of the group of companies, by charging intercompany compensation such as interest or guarantee fees at market rates on the transaction date.

  • In the case of approving related party transactions with commercial terms similar to those that a reasonable person would enter into with a general counterparty under the same circumstances, with commercial bargaining power free from the influence of individuals who are directors, executives, or related persons, by the management or the executive committee as authorized by the Board of Directors, the accounting staff must prepare a summary of transactions and send a confirmation letter of intercompany balances at the end of each month, and present it to the management. The management will then present all related party transaction information to the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors quarterly to ensure that the transactions are reasonable, provide maximum benefit to the Company, follow correct procedures, and comply with the agreed-upon terms approved by management, the Board of Directors, or the shareholders' meeting (as the case may be).

  • In cases where a connected transaction meets the criteria requiring shareholder approval, major shareholders with a conflict of interest may attend the meeting to constitute a quorum but shall not have the right to vote. The calculation of votes for approving connected transactions shall not include the votes of shareholders with a conflict of interest. Such rules shall not affect the quorum and voting rights. Any director or executive with a conflict of interest in a matter shall not have the right to vote and shall not participate in the consideration and approval of that matter.

The Board of Directors has considered the trend of future related party transactions, which are likely to remain limited to normal business transactions and normal business support transactions. The Company will strictly adhere to its established related party transaction policy.

The related party transactions likely to occur in the future are:

  1. The engagement of Belink Media Co., Ltd. to produce advertising media is due to Belink Media Co., Ltd. being the concessionaire for advertising billboard space in several educational institutions, which are the Company's primary target customer groups. The Company has fully complied with its related party transaction policy. B-Link Media Co., Ltd. has charged production fees at the same rate as other trading partners, calculated based on the area and complexity of the work.

  2. The Company pays for social media services, online applications, and online marketplaces using a specific credit card that must be issued in Mr. Chanwit's name, which is a designated credit card used exclusively for company payment transactions (Designated Credit Card). The Company is in the process of requesting an increase in the credit limit for credit cards issued in the Company's name with other financial institutions and changing payments on various online platforms to be made with the Company's credit card. However, some platforms still require the specific credit card issued in Mr. Chanwit's name because the credit limit of the credit card issued in the Company's name is not sufficient to cover the spending. Therefore, the Company is in the process of reducing the usage of such platforms to enable payment for services with the Company's credit card in the future. The Company has the following measures to control credit card spending:

  1. The said credit card is designated for company payment transactions only (Designated Credit Card). The credit card number is different from Mr. Chanvit's personal credit card number, and the letters "A/C" are marked on the card face to clearly indicate its separation from Mr. Chanvit's personal credit card. Accounting and finance officers can clearly verify the Company's spending transactions through credit card statements by checking the card number.

  2. The aforementioned credit card is kept at the Company, and no one can use this credit card for personal expenses.

  3. The Company does not transfer or reimburse credit card payments to Mr. Chanvit before the service provider sends the invoice to the Company. The marketing department will verify the invoice amount against marketing expenses, which are verifiable items, to summarize the amount payable to management. Accounting staff will be responsible for creating liabilities and recording invoice items, and the CFO will consider payment items (expenses recorded in the accounting system will only be the amount from social media invoices). This eliminates the risk of Mr. Chanwit receiving cash from the Company for personal use without repaying the issuing bank of the credit card.

  4. There are control points in place to ensure that the said credit card is not used for purposes inconsistent with those specified by the Company. Any transaction to be linked to the said credit card must first pass through the approval process and authority matrix. Accounting staff will cross-check that it is a social media spending item within the scope approved for linking to the said credit card before proceeding with the debt creation process.

Contents